Is open-plan living really the best way? Our Editor explores the pros and cons

Saturday, 21 January 2023 09:00

By Mary Goodsell

Open plan design in our living spaces has long been heralded as the solution to family harmony, but as heating costs rise and families grow and change, Adele Trathan questions whether wall-less really is best

From the earliest days of human civilisation, the heart of the family home has been the hearth. In fact, in the 15th century it wasn’t uncommon for British homes to consist of just one storey and one large room. So, whether cooking, working or sleeping, a family could benefit from the warmth of the fire.

Perhaps then, in this age where even young children generally have the privacy of their own bedrooms, our desire for intimacy while in the family living space is so vital to maintain this almost primitive desire for connection. Certainly, open plan living has been the dominant architectural trend for the past few decades with a seamless flow between kitchen, dining and lounge areas.

open-plan living

The positives
There are still many reasons why such design is so coveted. It is a sociable way of living; you can cook in the kitchen while chatting to your partner who is, perhaps, relaxing on the sofa; or keep an eye on your children who are doing their homework on the dining table.

It is also an effective way to give a smaller space – especially an apartment – a sense of capaciousness. That cubbyhole kitchen suddenly becomes a minimalist kitchenette diner when you remove a wall, creating comfort and connection where once was obstructive concrete.

open-plan living

The negatives
However, the tide is starting to turn against the utopian idea of the open plan home, particularly given the recent increase in fuel costs, those without inner walls are realising how much more expensive it is to heat a large spaces. Also, the practical and contemporary benefits of tiles and wood flooring can make a cavernous room feel colder still.

There is also a point where intimacy becomes an intrusion on privacy. Cooking smells permeate every area of the space until you are still being reminded of the fish pie you cooked for dinner while watching the end credits of the film you settled on the sofa to watch afterwards.

Noise echoes, too. The sound of a TikTok video your teenager is watching on their phone interrupts you as you try to read a book across the room.

In other words, what at first seemed as if it would bring you together as a family, is slowly making you all want to retreat to your bedrooms for a little peace and quiet.

open-plan living

Middle ground
Just as you wouldn’t use a sledgehammer to crack a nut, you don’t need to remove all walls (or put them all back up) to find harmony in the home. Instead, savvy interior designers and architects are coming up with solutions that make modern houses a little more flexible and intuitive. Sliding doors – preferably ones that can be tucked away out of sight – help to create cosiness when it is required.

Then, during the summer months when heating isn’t an issue, you can open out the space again, letting the air flow freely.

There is also a focus on insulation and triple glazing: features which increase house prices in the future as living costs increase and environmental impacts become even more of a priority.

In conclusion then, it seems that our love affair with open plan may well be drawing to a close, but only so long as we can move towards a living style that maintains our desire for integration while also being more practical.

open-plan living

More from Homes and Gardens

Home Style: Modern Outlook

Downsizing couple Pauline and Bill chose practicality over space, but didn’t compromise on their love of mid-century style
Blooming Times: Dahlia Mania

Inexpensive, hardworking plants with blooms in a vast array of colours and shapes - no flower is perfect, but dahlias come pretty close, says Flo Whitaker
Home Style: Time to Heal

After losing her husband, Tracy Nors threw all her energies into renovating a period terrace in the pretty town of Rye
Blooming Times: Spring into Summer

Say the word ‘bulb’ and thoughts of spring immediately come to mind - but there are some bulbus characters to plant now for summer colour. Flo Whitaker selects a few of her favourites
Home Style: Farm Stay

While living in a tiny cabin on the family farm, Freddie and Katie Pack saved up to build their dream house on a plot a few fields away
Home Style: Romantic Vision

Tim and Jenny Backshall rescued a derelict timber-framed hall house, respecting its history while future proofing for generations to come
Homes Extra: Dining Style

Sara Whatley is singing the praises of the dining table and looking at different styling options for it
Blooming Times: Spring Fever

February is often labelled the cruellest month in the horticultural calendar. However, Flo Whitaker suggests there is still plenty of opportunity for growth
Home Style: Forest Idyll

Moving the kitchen became the start of a much bigger project for the Buckinghams, as it created opportunities to change their new home
Blooming Times: What's in a Name?

Botanical Latin may seem daunting, but it’s designed to be helpful and informative, says Flo Whitaker
Gardening: The Benefits of Hedges

Gardeners are a flower-obsessed lot, greedily seeking out the latest, brightest blooms. That’s all very well, but ephemeral flowers need a stage to perform on. Plant a hedge - they add structure, benefit wildlife and look good all year round.
Home Style: Treasure Trove

The interior of a quaint, white-washed cottage in Sussex has been transformed into a colourful home full of character by a couple of keen collectors.
Blooming Times: Awesome Alliums

Easy-going and beloved by bees - now’s the perfect time to plant allium bulbs for a spectacular display next year. Flo Whitaker picks some of her favourites.
Homes Extra: Truly, Madly, Deeply

Fall in love with your soft furnishings again this autumn and make it the season to snuggle up in style, says Sara Whatley
Home Style: Clear Vision

Jacqui Elliott Williams has relished bringing this elegant Victorian house back to life with confident ideas, stylish choices and creative flair.
Homes Extra: Parasol Power

Pretty parasols are enjoying their moment in the sun and making our outside spaces spin with style, says Sara Whatley.
Blooming Times Garden Lore - Fact or Fiction?

The horticultural world abounds with bad advice and old wife’s tales, but some pronouncements are scientifically sound, says Flo Whitaker, as she asks, “True, or false?”
Home Style: Beaming with Happiness

Lisa and Matthew Good wanted a property to add value to, sell and move on – but they ended up so enamoured with their renovation that they decided to stay put.
Sussex Homes: Transforming a dark and unloved cottage into a Greek Escape

Helen Robinson has transformed a dark and unloved cottage from 1837 into a bright and inviting space with a Mediterranean feel in St Leonards-on-Sea.
Sussex Homes: Transforming a once unloved oast into a colourful and funky family abode

Sam Fallon, who works in advertising and husband Nick, who works in publishing have transformed a once unloved oast into a colourful and funky family abode near Tunbridge Wells for themselves and their daughters Tilly and Isobel.

Is open-plan living really the best way? Our Editor explores the pros and cons

Share

More from Homes and Gardens