Check out our latest magazine... Read Online

The Education Deliberation: Analogue or Digital?

The way we learn is evolving but, as Adele Trathan reports, research continues to highlight the benefits of traditional pen and paper note-taking over digital methods for students’ learning and retention

We are living through a phase of rapid technological innovation, where the methods and processes we held true for decades and centuries are now being questioned. Certainly, this reality is never more pertinent in the way we consume information, especially for educational means.

Yet a recently-published study of students across 10 countries that examined the tools by which we choose to learn, revealed a preference
for the writing of notes, over the use of computers, laptops and digital tools.

The results demonstrated the positive impact on learning and knowledge retention that the physical act of writing provides. This preference was particularly noted in the challenges when students attempted to write mathematical and scientific formulas on computers.

The Times Higher Education magazine – formerly the Times Higher Education Supplement – says that despite the practical advantages of digital devices, such as ease of information search and correction, the tactile and cognitive engagement of handwriting offers distinct learning advantages.

Furthermore, the publication Science Daily noted University of Tokyo research showing that writing on paper can lead to more brain activity when recalling information an hour later compared to using digital devices. This suggests that the act of writing by hand may foster better memory retention and understanding of the material.

Supporting this, experiments by researchers at Princeton and UCLA found that students who took notes on laptops performed worse in understanding lecture content compared to those who used pen and paper.

The hypothesis is that typing notes can lead to a more verbatim recording of information without substantive processing, whereas handwriting requires summarising and condensing the material, thus engaging more deeply with the content.

 

ADVANTAGES OF PEN AND PAPER

Handwriting notes with pen and paper offers several practical advantages:

● The physical act of writing aids in the cognitive process of learning, helping to encode information into memory more effectively.

● Students can more easily personalise notes with symbols, drawings and annotations, aiding in comprehension and retention.

●  Enhanced focus by reducing the distractions commonly associated with digital devices.

●  Handwriting can be especially beneficial for complex subjects that involve formulas, diagrams, or spatial information.

 

ADVANTAGES OF COMPUTERS

Despite the benefits of handwriting, computers offer their own set of advantages for students:

● Digital notes can be easily edited, searched and organised, offering a level of flexibility and efficiency that is hard to achieve with paper notes.

●  Access to online resources and information is instantaneous, enriching the learning experience with a wider range of materials.

●  Typing can be faster for many people, allowing for more comprehensive notes in some cases.

●  Finally, digital tools offer various ways to collaborate and share materials with peers and instructors.

One possible solution to the conundrum of choice might be found in the integration of traditional handwriting and digital technology. The advent of devices like styluses and tablets, which simulate the experience of writing on paper, blurs the boundaries between analogue and digital note-taking, presenting a multidimensional approach to learning. These tools merge the hands-on, cognitive advantages of handwriting with the streamlined organisational and editing features offered by digital platforms.

Alternatively, adopting a hybrid model promotes active participation in learning, utilising the best of both worlds: the tactile, memory-aiding practice of writing by hand and the convenience and broad accessibility of digital resources. For example, start with handwriting notes to capture the essence of lectures bolstering comprehension and memory; then, transfer this information to a digital format for further organisation and study. This harnesses the efficiency of technology, making review and application more effective.

Ultimately, where study is concerned, personal preference will always determine the terms and, to a large extent, the outcome.

 

More from Features

  • Weddings: Celebrate with a Celebrant!

    Sussex Celebrant, Beth Kirkham talks to Sara Whatley about her first job in a wedding dress shop, her most unusual requests, and being part of someone’s special day

  • Romantic Getaways

    Celebrate Valentine’s Day with a romantic getaway, Lisa de Silva says it’s the perfect opportunity to rekindle your love and escape the dark and gloomy skies

  • Home Style: Two Become One

    Alison Pike used her design skills to convert two semi-detached farm workers’ houses into a spacious family home with quirky touches

  • Spotlight Events: February 2025

    Your guide to all the best local events happening near you this month

  • What to Watch in February 2025

    From the return of Bridget Jones to a demonic monkey, here's the best of all the new films and TV shows headed to our screens in February

  • Money Matters: Go For Broke

    At a time when making money work for us seems as important as ever, it’s interesting to see that there is possible value in broken, non-working or incomplete items on online selling platforms

  • If You Ask Me: It's Time For a Revolution

    ‘Start as you mean to go on’ goes the phrase – so Flo Whitaker’s kicking off 2025 by planning a revolution

  • Holiday Money Saving Tips

    Planning your holiday for 2025? Whether you are watching the pennies or want to get a good deal, Lisa de Silva suggests ways to make your holiday budget work hard

  • Home Style: Perfect Fit

    Alex and David transformed a small cottage into a spacious home that fits and flows perfectly for their family

  • Winter Woodland Walks

    Let’s go play in the woods! Come rain or shine Sara Whatley and her brood love a good yomp through the trees – along with a bit of den building of course

  • Homes Extra: Home Sanctuary

    Start as you mean to go on by creating your very own home sanctuary, a place to relax and enrich your life, says Sara Whatley

  • Coping with Midlife Anxiety

    Anxiety UK’s Dave Smithson speaks to Sara Whatley about how the midlife population is experiencing anxiety, and what to do about it

  • You're a Natural Beauty!

    Each month Adele Trathan and Sara Whatley look at seven elements of living the life of a natural beauty, helping you to enrich the mind, body and soul in balance and holistic harmony

  • Good Night, Sleep Tight

    Having trouble sleeping? Lisa Artis, Deputy CEO of The Sleep Charity is here to help with her exclusive sleep insight and guidance

  • 10 Ways to Live Longer

    We all strive for longevity in life – we want to maximise each day, each experience and each other. Adele Trathan offers ten ways to help achieve this goal

  • What to Watch in January 2025

    Your guide to all the best new films and TV shows coming to screens in January....

  • Home Style: Ancient & Modern

    Recycling architecture is a concept that fascinates designer Mirka McNeill Farmer. Her talent for creating a unique character property is clearly evident with this mix of ancient and modern

  • Spotlight Events: January 2025

    Your guide to the best local events happening near you this month...

  • Fashion: 5 Trends for 2025

    Adele Trathan has a sneaky peek into the hot fashion trends that will dominate the quarter-century as we look at five styles for 2025

  • Money Matters: £5 Per Day to Jet Away

    Adele Trathan explains how just £5 per day can set you off on that dream holiday, with tips on making small changes to make your dreams a reality